 |
Sponsored by INCON CORPORATION |
|
See Also:
|
Main Index > Markets > Horticultural Applications > Potting Soils > Comparative Growth Studies Comparative
Growth Studies Perlite vs. Polystrene Media
Previous measurements of physical properties of
growing media comparing perlite with polystyrene beads have indicated higher density and
moisture retention when perlite
Watering Schedule Varied
Containers used in growth trials were 6 inch plastic pots, 20 for each mix, 1400 milliliters of mix per pot. All pots were seeded to perennial ryegrass at the same time and maintained moist for 1 week at which time uniform germination had occurred. Beginning with the second week, the watering schedule was varied according to the schedule shown in Table 2. The water that was supplied contained a balanced soluble nutrient and was supplied to each pot in the amount of 500 milliliters per pot at each scheduled irrigation. The excess liquid from each pot was collected and returned to the pot and drainage water was again collected, volume measured and recorded before discarding. "...SAMPLES PLANTED IN POLYSTYRENE BEAD MIX AND WATERED ONCE EVERY 4 DAYS FAILED TO PRODUCE ADDITIONAL GROWTH AFTER 12 WEEKS." Clippings Weighed The use of ryegrass as the test crop permitted successive harvests at which time clippings were dried and weighed. Harvests were made at 4, 8, 12, 16 and 20 weeks The maximum volume of water retained after drainage was determined to be 583 milliliters for the peat/perlite mix and 383 milliliters for the peat/polystyrene bead mix (1400 milliliters volume of mix). During the course of the growth trials, some unusually high temperatures occurred in the greenhouses which placed severe stress on crops under the limited irrigation regime. The five ryegrass samples planted in a polystyrene bead mix and watered once every 4 days failed to produce additional growth after 12 weeks.
Results Growth, as measured by quantity of clipping yield (see curve), was best in most frequently water samples. Visual inspection confirmed parallel root development. The order of growth rating from highest to lowest was: Perlite A, Perlite B, Polystyrene A, Perlite C, Polystyrene B, Perlite D, Polystyrene C, Polystyrene D. "PERLITE CONTRIBUTES TO MOISTURE SUPPLY OF THE MEDIA TO A GREATER DEGREE THAN POLYSTYRENE BEADS." Moisture utilization followed the same pattern that was noted for growth. Rating from highest moisture utilization to lowest was: Perlite A, Polystyrene A, Perlite B, Perlite C, Polystyrene D. Differences between Polystyrene A and Perlite B were minimal. Thus, irrigation every other day in the perlite mix was equivalent to irrigation every day in the polystyrene mix, and irrigation every 3 days in the perlite mix was equivalent to irrigation every 2 days in the polystyrene mix. "POLYSTYRENE BEADS ARE INFERIOR TO PERLITE AS AN ADDITIVE IN GROWING MEDIA." Conclusions Growth and water use as measured in this set of studies confirm previous physical measurements of mixes prepared with perlite and polystyrene beads. Perlite contributes to moisture supply of the media to a greater degree than polystyrene beads. For some reason, growth was superior in Perlite B compared to Perlite A, both of which were provided about the same amount of moisture. Apparently, some other restricting factor in the polystyrene bead mix limited growth. Under conditions of high stress (irrigation every third or fourth day), perlite media out-performed polystyrene bead media. From a cultural standpoint, polystyrene beads are inferior to perlite as an additive in growing media. |
|||||||||||||||||||
|
Information given herein is from sources considered
reliable, but no guarantee of accuracy can be made or liability assumed. Your
supplier may be able to provide you with more precise data. Certain compositions or
processes involving perlite may be the subject of patents. |
||||||||||||||||||||
Accumulative yield of clippings of ryegrass grown in perlite media and
polystyrene media at four different irrigation schedules.